S. Bear Bergman, a well-known queer theorist, describes the show as following "the formula of the Saturday Night Live sketch" (those hourlong one-man SNL sketches they do all the time) and was disappointed that the show wasn't more "salacious":
"You know, the kind in which the performer would bite his lip like a bad boy and say something along the lines of “…which turned out to be more fun than I was expecting, even if I did eventually have to throw out all the bedsheets and wash my cat in dish soap.”
Not to worry, we're currently working hard to amp up Dave's lip-biting "bad boy" factor and are writing Bergman's hilarious dialogue fragment into the show immediately!
To be fair, I think Bergman's retitling of the show is funny and completely accurate, "Every Relationship Mistake I Made Before I Met You, Only Some Of Which I Seem To Have Learned From."
But it wasn't all bad, Bergman conceded this point at the end of the review: "On the other hand, the audience applauded wildly when the show was over, so certainly the show appealed to some people."
Come see the show this weekend and judge for yourself!